The following are Web Site Links and descriptions of resources for those of you dealing with an emotionally distant spouse. We pray they will help you in your marital situation:
• Rejoiceministries.org This entire ministry, is designed to encourage and give hope to those who are standing in the gap believing God for a miracle in their marriages. They supply its reader’s more than 18 pages of testimonies of restored marriages and over 72 pages where you’re able to read individual letters of praise to God for answers to prayer and testimonies of God’s faithfulness through the various difficulties they’ve encountered in their marriages and families. You can read the testimonies and the stories of restored marriages by clicking into them from the side bar of the Home page of their web site.
• Retrouvaille.org. (meaning “rediscovery” and rhymes with pie) This is a program for couples with serious problems that are disillusioned, separated and/or on the brink of divorce. You’ll be helped by volunteer couples who have also “been to the brink” —who have experienced serious problems including affairs, alcoholism, gambling, violence, etc. or who have simply fallen out of love —but who have worked their way back. They’ll teach you how to fall back in love again and heal your own marriage and make it stronger than ever before. This successful program (85% when both partners work at it) teaches simple techniques of communication and exercises to work on forgiveness, healing, and restoration of trust.
The program begins with a weekend and includes 12 follow-up meetings over 3 months. These are not spiritual retreats, sensitivity groups, seminars or social gatherings —there are no counselors involved and you don’t have to say anything in front of anyone else. Couples discuss the topics and practice the skills in private. It has a blank envelope -donation system and is open to couples of all faiths and to the non-religious. For those in the USA: to find a program in your area call, 800-470-2230 or you can visit their web site.
RESOURCES:
• Attachments: Why You Love, Feel, and Act the Way You Do – written by Dr Tim Clinton and Dr Gary Sibcy, published by Thomas Nelson. This book addresses why people feel and act the ways they do. The authors say that how successfully we form and maintain relationships throughout life is related to early issues of “attachment.” They cite four primary bonding styles that explain why people love, feel, and act they way they do. This book is for those who desire closeness, especially in the most intimate relationships: marriage, parenting, close friends, and ultimately with God.
• Because I Said Forever: Embracing Hope in an Imperfect Marriage -by Deb Kalmbach and Heather Kopp, published by Multnomah Publishers. This book is a compilation of true testimonies on various subjects of marriage lived out by different women who have and are living through some really tough situations and yet God has helped them to live victoriously despite the difficulties. The authors have done an excellent job of “applying biblical principles to the challenging issues involved in a difficult marriage.” Women who read this book will “understand how doing things God’s way brings fulfillment and peace, regardless of the circumstances.” Too often divorce becomes the prime option considered when marriage becomes really tough. The great thing about this book is it gives the readers some different biblically based options to consider.
• How We Love -written by Milan and Kay Yerkovich, published by Water Brook. The authors of this book “draw on the tool of an attachment theory to show how your early life experiences created an ‘intimacy imprint’ —an underlying blueprint that shapes your behavior, beliefs, and expectations of all relationships, especially your marriage. They identify four types of injured imprints that combine in marriage to trap couples in a repetitive dance of pain. The principles and solution-focused tools in this book will equip you to… – identify the imprints disrupting your marriage – understand how your love style impacts your mate – break free of negative patterns that hinder your relationship – enhance your sexual intimacy, and – create a deeper, richer marriage.”
• Love Must Be Tough: New Hope for Marriages in Crisis, by Dr James Dobson, published by Multnomah Publishers. In this book, Dr. Dobson offers practical help for the spouse who wants to hold the marriage together. He shows how to rekindle romantic interest and draw the offending partner back home. For new generations faced with ever-increasing threats to stable and loving bonds, Love Must Be Tough offers realistic hope.
“Dr. Dobson’s premise of tough love, which essentially means defining and maintaining the line of respect around yourself, seems sound and practical. Applying it avoids the drawn-out, torturous emotions that go with living in a decaying relationship. Dobson makes the seemingly radical recommendation that people facing infidelity or other marital crisis of similar proportions precipitate a crisis to bring the situation to a boil. Dobson’s point is that that boil will very often restore the relationship. Precipitating the crisis shows your mettle, which commands respect and even admiration. This book is NO GUARANTEE that you will win your spouse or significant other back. But, like anything else, if you don’t do something you will more assuredly lose them anyway. Pray hard and read this book if you want to keep them. Learn to give them space.”
• Love & Respect – By Dr Emerson Eggerichs, a Focus on the Family Book, published by Integrity Publishers. This is a marriage book that makes a difference! It delivers a revolutionary message. People are saying about this book: “I’ve been married 35 years and have not heard this taught.” … “This is the key that I have been missing.” … “It caused a light bulb moment for me.” … “You connected all the dots for me.” … “As a counselor, I’ve never been so excited about any material.” … “You’re on to something huge here.” Discover the single greatest secret to a successful marriage: “Psychological studies affirm it, and the Bible has been saying it for ages. Cracking the communication code between husband and wife involves understanding one thing: that unconditional respect is as powerful for him as unconditional love is for her. It’s the secret to marriage that every couple seeks, and yet few couples ever find.” “Love and Respect” reveals why spouses react negatively to each other, and how they can deal with such conflict quickly, easily and biblically. Based on over three decades of counseling, as well as scientific and biblical research, Dr. Emerson Eggerichs and his wife, Sarah, have already taken the “Love and Respect” message across America and are changing the way couples talk to, think about, and treat each other.
•The Best Thing I Ever Did for My Marriage: 50 Real Life Stories -Nancy Cobb and Connie Grigsby, published by Multnomah Publishers. This book contains 50 eye-opening, often humorous true stories—including contributions from Cynthia Heald, Dee Brestin, Rosemary Jensen, and Donna Otto—that will inspire you with moments that build stronger marriages. It inspires you to: bring down walls between you and your husband, adjust to differences in your personalities, deal with the damage and heartbreak of betrayal, and go on living when everything goes terribly wrong. As the authors, Nancy Cobb and Connie Grisby say about this book (and we agree with) “You’re about to embark on an eye-opening journey that we believe you’ll walk away from feeling hopeful and inspired. The women in this book have walked in your shoes! With refreshing honesty and insight, they share the struggles in their marriages and what got them on track again. And the masks have been dropped! Regardless of whether every chapter applies to you or not, we think you’ll be encouraged and heartened. Each chapter offers insight to help you build a stronger marriage, while sharing inspirational truths about God’s design for your life.”
• The Emotionally Destructive Marriage: How to Find Your Voice and Reclaim Your Hope – written by Leslie Vernick, published by Waterbrook Press. This book is for any woman caught in an emotionally destructive marriage. In it, Leslie offers a personalized path forward. Based on decades of counseling experience, her intensely practical, biblical advice will show you how to establish boundaries and break free from emotional abuse. Learn to: – identify damaging behaviors – gain the skills to respond wisely – promote healthy change – stay safe – understand when, why, and even how to leave (if that’s necessary) – recognize that God sees and hates what is happening to you. This book comes HIGHLY recommended by many counselors.
• The Walk-Out Woman: When Your Heart is Empty and Your Dreams Are Lost, written by Dr Steve Stephens and Alice Gray, published by Multnomah. We HIGHLY recommend this book. It’s written for women who need practical and inspiring help to breathe new life into their marriages, which may seem hopeless. As the authors say, concerning this book, “We pray that you will recognize the symptoms and dangers of becoming a walk-out woman and that you will realize that it is not a path to happiness. Opening your heart to your marriage again is indeed a risk, but we believe it’s a risk worth taking. We want to help you understand your husband better and show some ways you can encourage him to listen to your hurts and anger. We want to help you understand more about yourself as well —why you may have started “keeping score” and how you have built a wall around your heart. We’ll talk about realistic and unrealistic expectations and the dangers of creating a new fantasy with someone else. We’ll also give you strategies for taking care of yourself, getting connected again with your husband, resolving conflict, dealing with anger and loss, remembering the good times, and pressing closer to the Lord.”
• The Wounded Woman: Hope and Healing for Those Who Hurt -written by Dr Steve Stephens and Pam Vredevelt, published by Multnomah Publishers. This is a good book for women filled who are finding it difficult to cope with some of the tragedies that plague them. It offers you the pathway to regain your footing, restart your life, recover your energy, and reclaim your joy. Contained within its pages are real-life testimonies that will guide you toward recovery and inspire you to press forward in new found strength —not in spite of your wounds but because of them. As Dr Stephens says, “We cannot change the past. What has occurred —with all of its hurt, injustice, cruelty, disappointment, and tragedy —has slipped into history, beyond our control. Even so, we can change how we view the painful realities that have touched our life and what we say to ourselves about those realities.” The mission of this book is to help you move forward as you work through your pain, “reminding you that there is hope —that you’re not alone. God never promised to keep us from wounds, but He did promise to be with us and to help us heal.”
• When Love Dies How To Save A Hopeless Marriage -written by Judy Bodmer, published by Word Publishing. This is a refreshing, honest look at one woman’s journey to the edge of divorce, her commitment to stay even though she didn’t feel like it, and her eventual rediscovery of the love that she thought had died. Some of the subjects she discusses from her own experience are: You Don’t Know How Bad Things Are; You Don’t Know My Husband; I Can’t Forgive or Forget, I Can’t Change the Way I Feel; I had So Many Dreams; I Don’t Love Him; We Can’t Talk; I Feel So Angry; I Married the Wrong Man; I Don’t Want Him to Touch Me; I Don’t Feel Loved; and I Just Want to Be Happy.
• When Work and Family Collide -written by Andy Stanley, published by Multnomah Publishers. This book presents a strategic plan for resolving the tension between work and home. You’ll find ways to deal with the busyness that wreaks havoc with the relationships you consider most important. As Dr John Maxwell says about this book [which we agree]: “This is a life-changing book and extremely relevant to our modern way of life. Author Andy Stanley confronts us with truth and transparency. Just as he had made a commitment in his own life to balance his family time with his work, he encourages us to make similar commitments. One of the main reasons it is life changing is because a godly man who makes choices in his own life to never sacrifice his family for success has written it. If he wins the world but loses his family, what has he gained? Every couple, every parent, and every leader needs to read this book and consider the question: Who wins when my family and work collide?”
(AMERICA) I have a question can anyone help me with it?
(USA) You can ask. I’m not sure if anyone can help until we know what you are asking.
(AMERICA) I was wondering why it’s always the woman’s job to make the marriage better or to start to make the marriage better??? It’s like the men don’t ever have a clue about anything. Or of the marriage is in trouble or not. Men are clueless.
(USA) Diane, I’m sure you realize that this is an exaggeration that it’s “always” the woman who strives to make the marriage better. You can find comments in most any of the articles on this web site, which are authored by men who are trying to save their marriage.
But statistically, it is often the wife who is the first to try to get help for the marriage one way or another. And often she is the first to give up on the marriage (probably because she gets tired of trying, but that’s supposition on my part). I’m sure I’ll have many men who will try to argue me down on this matter. They won’t succeed but they will try. We see what comes in to Marriage Missions behind the scenes (& talk with many, many counselors and what I believe is backed up by our experience on this).
You’re right in saying though, that some men are clueless (as there are women who are clueless). But to bunch them all together is probably not very helpful. I’ve learned that it’s best to take each case individually. Getting hot under the collar at all “clueless” men will just add heat to your ire in all of this. Let go of that which you cannot change and work on that which you can change and you will be MUCH further ahead.
I see that your next comment asks about specifics. I want you to know that we are going to post it and pray about answering it tomorrow (hoping others will try to help you, as well). I’m truly sorry for your pain. May God give you a good night’s sleep tonight.
(USA) Cindy, my question is, what is the difference between a man who really is clueless and one who is emotionally distant? The result is the same. I’ve been married 20 years, both Christians… my husband is a good man, but he is either completely clueless about how to nurture relationships, or he is stunted in some way. I strongly believe it has at least something to do with his father …never physically abusive, but has anger issues and blamed my husband for things, embarassed him by yelling at him, and other things. But when I have tried to talk about our situation and deal with our reality (that it is totally impacting our marriage AND our son), he shuts down.
He’s evasive, gets mad/explodes, avoids direct answers, changes the subject, or just leaves. I have tried everything under the sun, read books, prayed, said nothing, said it hundreds of different ways… trying to connect, to understand him, to help him be comfortable and express whatever’s in his head/heart… but he is SO not in touch with himself, that he will do almost ANYTHING to avoid talking about important issues.
I know he loves me, but I mostly don’t feel it. He knows this. I know he worries about upsetting me b/c he doesn’t know what to say, because he’s told me so. We went through bankruptcy and losing our home (shortsell) a couple years ago, and I had to do 98% of everything -recognizing the problem, finding an attorney, gathering documents, making phone calls, etc. I was the one who had to find another place to live, while homeschooling. He was not there for me very often.
He is an amazing manager, and he works like crazy and gets more done at work than any 3 people… most of his superiors have said he’s the smartest guy in the room… yet he can’t get promoted. I totally think whatever is impacting our marriage is defeating him at work. But he doesn’t want to talk about it -not w/me, not w/his dad, my dad, my brother, not a pastor, no one from work, not a counselor. He will do almost ANYTHING to avoid dealing with his shortcomings.
To me, if you have a problem, you look it straight in the face and deal with it… if you don’t, then you’re just running from it and nothing changes. He actually believes this… but doesn’t apply it.
My heart aches for our 14 year old son, who adores both his parents. I know it hurts him when his dad blows up at me or when his dad can’t hug him warmly and smile and be sincere about expressing love. It’s always kind of a joke or something, and our son good naturedly laughs it off saying he knows dad loves him. But I KNOW there is a longing in our son for that kind of appropriate touch, and sincere, warm fatherly love.
So is my husband clueless, stubborn, a fool, or wounded? He won’t talk about mistakes, but he has other issues I think are all related to something he is still running from. He’s 51, in great shape. I used to think he was the most independent man I ever met, not really even needing me or our son… but after reading several “marriage messages” and this “distant spouse” section, I really think my intuition has it right. I think he’s very insecure, and has found a way to deal with it by assuming a complete perfectionistic, manager, calm cool, collected, never panics type of response. But it’s all a filter… a sham. He can’t be who he really is. I’m not even sure he knows who he is.
For years I tried to connect and would say that he was missing out on so much of life by not being aware of his feelings… it’s the strangest thing I’ve ever encountered. I want to make things better… I want for us to have a warmer, healthier relationship so we are modeling a godly marriage to our son and neighbors. I want to break the chain of destructive/evasive fatherhood. I am totally open to learning about my shortcomings too. But I am really curious about my question -is there hope for my husband? Is he even capable of understanding any of this???
Rachel, I’ve been praying about what to write to you in reply to your questions. You ask if “there is hope” for your husband to somehow change and become emotionally closer to you and your son… “is he even capable of understanding” the changes that need to be made?” My answer is yes. I’ve seen it happen, but I have to say that I don’t know if this will happen with your husband. There are so many variables involved. We all have a free will and whether or not your husband will allow himself to be vulnerable enough to seek help to make those changes, I don’t know.
But I do know that I GREATLY admire your tenacity and perseverance in trying to get your husband to get a clue. I know he has a beating heart in there somewhere, or he wouldn’t be alive. But as for the heart of your marriage and family, you are obviously the one who is bringing the emotional “heart” or connectivity into your home. I thank God for the gift you have and that you’ve been willing to use it. Your son, especially, will be all the more rich because of it. I pray you don’t “lose heart” as the scriptures say, and give up “for in the proper time we will reap a harvest if we do not give up.”
I have no doubt that 20 years seems like an eternity. And in the timetable that we humans put onto it, it is. But I was just reading a blog today, written by Chris –a wife from the midwest, who wrote the following, “After 20 years of being a sexual gatekeeper and refuser, I am now learning to dance with desire and enjoy the full intimacy that comes with passionate and joyful sex with the husband God provided for me.” In this blog she wrote further, “My husband had his access to emotional and physical intimacy controlled by me for two decades. He has seen me change. I’ve atoned for my sin, in both thought and deed. My husband has forgiven me, and so has my God. Most of the time, I can even say I’ve forgiven myself. I thank God that my husband did not think I was beyond redemption, and I mean that in the fullness of the definition, not just theologically.” (You can read the entire blog at: http://forgivenwife.wordpress.com/2013/04/18/beyond-redemption/.)
For 20 years she kept herself at a distance, but she has since changed all that. The reason I point this out is to give you hope. I hope it’s not false hope, but I really don’t believe it is. Whenever we become God’s colleague in helping another human being to love in a manner where we and others are better able to comprehend and know it –particularly when it’s our own spouse, we have partnered with the best. God is a redeemer –our redeemer, and He is able to bring some type of good out of everything we bring to Him –no pain is ever wasted. No effort that we make with His guidance ever goes forth without some type of good coming out of it.
You ask if your husband is either “clueless” or “stunted in some way.” I don’t know, Rachel. But I have a feeling that both are involved. There is a book written by Milan and Kay Yerkovich, that I believe could help. It’s titled, How We Love: Discover Your Love Style, Enhance Your Marriage. I heard an interview with the authors on a Focus on the Family broadcast. They had personally struggled for about 15 years of their marriage before they finally started to realize “core patterns” that can influence how we interact with our spouse. The book explains this better than I can but upon learning how to deal with their own marriage problems they learned how childhood experiences can influence how we interact with our spouse. In the book, they also give insights as to how to understand the “attachment styles” (or unattached styles) and how to work them through to get to a healthier place.
I encourage you to get the book, prayerfully read it and ask God to show you what to do with the information you learn. I did that in different ways with my husband when we had marital problems a number of years ago and by doing little things and saying little things and conveying little things that I was learning, Steve eventually woke up and started participating in our marriage and now he is a GREAT husband and communicator. I can’t guarantee you the same thing, but I sure think it’s worth a try. You tried different things before, perhaps this book can give you new insights, which may help.
I know that a call-in show called “New Life Live” sometimes has Milan Yerkovich as one of their on-air counselors who answers questions. Here’s a web site link to tell of some of their broadcasts: http://newlife.com/broadcasts. Perhaps you can call in and see about talking with Milan or one of the other counselors on the air (even changing your name). Here’s another link that answers questions about their broadcasts: http://newlife.com/broadcasts/faq. It’s worth a try, if you can talk to them. But you may want to obtain the book first and read it. It’s up to you. Rachel, I hope this helps in some way. I wish I could help more than this, but please pray about it and see how God leads. I pray that somehow your husband opens up and that you and your son are able to enjoy not only the outside benefits of being with this “hard-working man” but also the inside benefits of learning more about what is in his heart and mind. I pray for you and your husband and your son.” And this is my prayer: that your love may abound more and more in knowledge and depth of insight, so that you may be able to discern what is best and may be pure and blameless until the day of Christ, filled with the fruit of righteousness that comes through Jesus Christ –to the glory and praise of God.” (Philippians 1:9-11)
(U.S.A) I felt like all the help books were geared toward women too and felt similar feelings.
(AMERICA) Also the problem in my marriage is that my husband is always flirty with other women in front of me on purpose just to make me mad. I have put up with this for years and years. He knows i dont like it. But does this all the time. its to the point now that I don’t feel like going anywhere with him. I don’t enjoy going anywhere with him cause this is what he does. He is really too old to do this, 63. Plus, I didn’t like it before. What should I do?? Plus with all this resentment I’m just about ready to stop sleeping with him. What should I do?
(U.S.A) My husband used to do that too, until one time I asked for the keys before we walked into a couple’s dessert at our church. Yes, even at a church function I could not be secure that he would not be inappropriate with other women. He asked why I wanted them and I told him that if he acted inappropriately I would just get up and leave and drive home and he would have to find his own ride home.
It has never happened again. Sad his motivation could not have been my heart, but at least I’m no longer humiliated in public. I’m a princess of the Lord on High and will not be treated less than.
(AMERICA) Ok Thanks. I hope someone helps me with the other problem.
(USA) I am a man. My wife has withdrawn from our relationship. She wants a divorce and wants our finances separated. I suffered a stroke 3 years ago and our roles completely reversed. After 3 years I am upright and vertical and pretty close to normal. For all I praise God.
But we were destroyed financially with med bills. No one will let me return to who I was. They treat me like I am disabled and have memory issues. I keep fighting to regain my position and no one will let me back up especially my wife and kids. This sucks. Can you give me a plan or program with prayer also to follow?
I am carrying this alone and very discouraged. My wife wants me out and to be independent. She resents me and no longer shows any respect. Help. I feel like a dog they all outgrew. We have been married 20 years. With 3 kids 19, 16, 13. Help! Thanx.
(NIGERIA) My husband constantly withdraws from me; it drives me batty. He reads the newspaper, surfs the web, disappears into his shed out the back or plays video games. He puts in no effort to connect with me. All conversations are initiated by me. He lives in his own world & is very self focused. This all started with the birth of our first child. HELP!